Skip to content

● Review desk · websites researched by hand

Document

Methodology

A step-by-step look at how we research, record and score each review, and at what a review is unable to tell you.

How a review is made

  1. Selection. The reviewer decides which website to cover. Readers are welcome to suggest sites, though we cannot promise to review every suggestion.
  2. Manual research. The reviewer personally examines the website and the public information that relates to it. We use no automated scanning and no AI-generated analysis.
  3. Documentation. Each observation is logged as a separate finding, and the reviewer drafts the written review.
  4. Assessment. The reviewer sets the Trust Score, then writes the risk assessment and the final verdict.
  5. Publication and maintenance. We publish the review together with the date of the research. If we find out about relevant changes or a confirmed factual mistake, the review is updated.

Areas we examine

The areas below are taken into account whenever they matter for the website and can actually be judged. Some of them will not apply to a particular site, and each review describes only the checks that were really performed for it.

Area 1

Who runs the website

Whether the operator is named, whether a company, address and working contact options are given, and whether these details agree with each other.

Area 2

Domain background

Public domain records the reviewer looks up by hand, for example how long the domain has existed and what registration details are visible.

Area 3

Visible security signals

Things any visitor can confirm in a browser, such as an HTTPS connection without certificate warnings. We do not run scanners or probe the website.

Area 4

Terms and policies

Whether terms, a privacy notice and rules on refunds, cancellations or withdrawals exist, are easy to find and are written clearly.

Area 5

Offer and claims

Whether products, prices and promises are explained clearly and realistically, and whether anything on the website looks misleading or inconsistent.

Area 6

Outside sources

Public information from elsewhere that the reviewer checks where it is relevant and accessible, such as official registers or published warnings.

Finding categories

The reviewer sorts every observation in a review into one of these groups:

  • Positive findings: points that count in the website’s favour.
  • Negative findings: points that cause concern or leave questions unanswered.
  • Security observations: simple security-related notes that a visitor could check for themselves.
  • Domain-related observations: notes drawn from public information about the domain.
  • Other findings: any further point the reviewer judged to be relevant.

About the Trust Score

The Trust Score condenses the reviewer’s overall view into a single number between 0 and 100. The reviewer chooses it after weighing all of the findings together. Nothing calculates it automatically, and the areas listed above carry no fixed weighting. Every score is an editorial opinion that applies to the moment the review was carried out.

ScoreBandMeaning
80–100 High Trust Our review found few or no concerns at the time of review.
60–79 Moderate Trust Some concerns or open questions were noted; read the findings.
40–59 Caution Several concerns were noted during the review; exercise caution.
0–39 Low Trust Significant concerns were noted during the review.

Risk levels

Every review also gives a risk level, which is one of the following: Low risk, Moderate risk, Elevated risk, High risk. Normally the risk level matches the band of the Trust Score. If the findings call for it, the reviewer can choose a different level and gives the reasons in the risk assessment.

What a review cannot cover

  • We work only from public information and from what any visitor can see; a website’s internal systems are out of our reach.
  • Security audits, penetration testing and malware analysis are not part of what we do.
  • Things may have changed since the review was written, so always look at the review and update dates.
  • A high score does not guarantee that a site is safe, and a low score does not prove fraud. Our Disclaimer covers this further.